Who Built the History We Think We Know?

Somewhere between history...and Hollywood...something strange happened.

The real people started disappearing.

This week on Ctrl + Alt + Delusion, Nate accidentally turns a relaxing movie night into a full-blown historical identity crisis after asking one innocent question during Tombstone:

"Did that actually happen?"

That single Google search uncovers a much bigger pattern.

Wyatt Earp wasn't the legend most of us grew up believing.

Braveheart borrowed heavily from centuries-old legend instead of documented history.

Disney's Pocahontas transformed a tragic real life into a romantic fairy tale.

And American Sniper raises uncomfortable questions about what happens when a real person becomes something larger than life.

But this episode isn't really about Hollywood.

It's about us.

Why do certain stories survive?

Who builds our heroes?

And what do the myths we inherit say about the people who created them?

This rabbit hole became something far bigger than we expected...and it may have accidentally launched an entirely new chapter for the Average Joe Nerdcast.

Sources discussed include:

Wyatt Earp

• John Mack Faragher (Wyatt Earp)
• Stuart Lake – Wyatt Earp: Frontier Marshal
• HistoryNet
• True West Magazine
• American Cowboy Chronicles

Braveheart

• Historical records on William Wallace
• Blind Harry's The Wallace
• Scotland's Stories
• Encyclopaedia Britannica
• Multiple historical analyses of Braveheart

Pocahontas

• Smithsonian Magazine (Camilla Townsend)
• Encyclopaedia Britannica
• The Indigenous Foundation
• Historical scholarship on Matoaka (Pocahontas)

American Sniper

• U.S. Navy records
• The Intercept
• Slate
• Foreign Policy
• Jesse Ventura defamation case records

Join the conversation in The Lobby and tell us:

What historical figure do you think deserves a second look?

Links to both groups

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1LbcoGmvKg/?mibextid=wwXIfr

Discord: https://discord.gg/Q5X3MFVx2

Average Joe Nerdcast © 2026

New episodes every Monday and Thursday (and sometimes Sunday).

Stay Gold.

Nerd Bold.

#History #Hollywood #Myths #WyattEarp #Braveheart #Pocahontas #AmericanSniper #HistoryFacts #MovieHistory #AverageJoeNerdcast